A.H. Bayly’s Long, Long Ago gets a new life in Volume 2 in a different key – G major, plus an interesting variation to teach an important new technique – upbow staccato bowing. It continues Volume 2’s theme of refining and consolidating the skill of playing in G major, one of the violin’s most common and important keys.

Shakespeare’s Globe Theatre
Shakespeare appears later…
Chorus from Judas Maccabaeus was Suzuki’s favourite tone study piece. He taught us the valuable habit of spending time at the start of a lesson or practice session to work on tone before all else. Virtually every one of his lessons began with this piece. He told us that he used a tonalization arpeggio exercise for this purpose for many years, but eventually recognised that students found it rather boring. So he changed over to Chorus.
Needless to say, several years of Chorus had the same effect. I use other Volume 2 pieces for tonalization and Long, Long Ago in particular. It has the added advantage of refining staccato tone as well as legato.
(Click here for Long, Long Ago in Volume 1.)
A Few Finer Points…
Having studied Long, Long Ago in Volume 1, students learn the G major melody in minutes, providing a good opportunity to look at some finer points. One is to check the intonation of the opening G visually as well as by listening. When G is exactly in tune, they can see the open G vibrate while playing the stopped note and find the precise point for maximum effect.
As with the Volume 1 version, crotchets (¼ notes) and minims (½ notes) are played with whole bows with smooth legato strokes, connecting the melody within the phrases.
B or Not B, that is the question. (Thanks and apologies to Shakespeare.)
Long, Long Ago in G major is a convenient stage to talk with students and parents about the small differences between the same notes in different keys – where they have different functions.
The note B (1st finger on A string) is played slightly sharper in G major than the B in some other keys – such as A major – due to its position in the key and scale. Without getting too technical, explain how it is a defining note in the major scale.
You can show the difference between the two Bs with the following exercise. First, make sure the violin is perfectly tuned!
- To find the B to use in the key of G major, play it together with a open E string, adjusting 1st finger until you hear the pure sound of a perfect 4th interval.
- For the ‘other’ B, first find the B as above. Without moving 1st finger, now try playing it with the open D string. Surprise! The major 6th interval sounds off – it is slightly too wide. Now flatten this B a little until it makes a sweet harmony with the D string. This B sounds better for keys such as A and D major.

The Variation
Read More →